Srinagar, Nov 18, KDC: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh quashed the preventive detention of a Kupwara resident under the Public Safety Act (PSA), observing that depriving him of personal liberty resulted from ‘police frivolity and the callous command of a District Magistrate ‘.
A single bench of Justice Rahul Bharti passed the judgment while allowing a habeas corpus petition filed by the wife of the detainee, Mohd Sadiq Mir. Mir had been lodged in District Jail, Udhampur, since May 5, 2025.
The detention order was issued by the District Magistrate, Kupwara, on May 3, 2025, acting on a dossier submitted by the Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kupwara, in April 2025. The authorities justified the detention by recording that Mir had a “long history of criminal activities” that posed a threat to the security of the State and the sovereignty and integrity of India.
However, upon examining the records, the High Court found that the only criminal antecedent available with the administration was a single FIR (No. 22/2014) registered at Police Station Kralpora. The case, involving charges of attempted murder and criminal conspiracy (Sections 307 and 120-B of the Ranbir Penal Code read with Section 7/25 of the Arms Act), is currently under trial before the Sessions Judge, Kupwara.
Terming the official recital of a long criminal history as “ex-facie misconceived and misplaced,” the Court said that a lone 2014 FIR was a “very distant incident to generate basis” for correlating the petitioner’s personal liberty as a threat to the State’s security in 2025.
Coming down heavily on the district administration, Justice Bharti said that the petitioner’s preventive detention was “nothing but a frivolity and fancy on the part of the respondent No. 3 – Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kupwara reciprocated by the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate Kupwara.”
Warning against the arbitrary deprivation of constitutional rights, the bench said, “If by this type personal liberty is allowed to be usurped by the District Police and District Magistrate in depriving a person of his most cherished fundamental right to personal liberty, then Article 21 of the Constitution of India would mean nothing but a lip service to a free citizen of India exposed to suffer preventive detention under preventive detention jurisdiction at any given point of time at the call of fancy of District Police and on the callous command of a District Magistrate.”
Ruling that the detention was entirely unjustified, the High Court quashed the May 2025 detention order along with any subsequent approval or extension orders. The Court directed the Superintendent of District Jail, Udhampur, to release the petitioner to his personal liberty forthwith. (KDC)

