Srinagar, Nov 21, KDC: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has pulled up district health officials and a team of doctors in Kashmir for terminating the 24-week pregnancy of a 13-year-old sexual assault victim without judicial authorisation while the matter was pending before it, observing that they “have taken the law in their hands” and acted in “clear violation” of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act, 1971.
Justice Moksha Khajuria Kazmi passed the order on Saturday while hearing a writ petition filed by the minor through her guardian. Taking serious note of the unilateral procedure, the Court directed the Chief Medical Officer (CMO), the Medical Superintendent (MS) of the concerned district hospital, Respondent No. 5, the four-member medical team, and the victim’s father to file personal affidavits and appear in person on November 25, 2026.
According to the court record, the accused in the sexual assault case is currently in custody under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, and relevant penal provisions. Earlier this month, the district Child Welfare Committee (CWC) wrote to the CMO seeking steps for terminating the minor’s pregnancy. Two days later, the CMO responded that her gestational age was approximately 22 to 24 weeks, exceeding the routine permissible limit under the MTP Act, and requested the CWC Chairperson to approach a competent court for legal sanction.
Following the filing of the writ petition, the High Court on November 17 directed the CMO to constitute a team of medical officers to ascertain the exact gestational period and submit a report by November 20.
On November 20, the government counsel placed on record a communication of the same date stating that the gestational age of the fetus was 24 weeks as on November 19. The report opined that termination was clinically indicated and warned that deferring the procedure beyond 24 weeks could render it clinically more difficult. The medical team—constituted on November 20 and signed off by the MS—comprised a Consultant Gynecologist, a Consultant Pediatrician, and Radiology Medical Officers. On November 20, the High Court passed an order regarding the termination of the pregnancy.
However, records produced before the bench on November 21 revealed that a Special Medical Board had already assessed the minor on November 19, reviewing ultrasound and clinical documents which, according to the MS, were unavailable 12 to 15 days earlier, and concluded that she needed to be admitted the same day for the procedure.
The MS informed the Court that the girl was admitted to the hospital on November 19—with the official record failing to mention whether the admission time was AM or PM—and that the Consultant Gynecologist obtained a consent form signed by the victim’s father, after which the medical team terminated the pregnancy.
The proceedings also revealed contradictory claims among the officials regarding communication of the November 19 decision. While the MS claimed the November 19 communication was sent to the CMO the same day, the CMO, present in person, stated it was not furnished to him until November 20. The government counsel also submitted that the November 19 communication was never provided to him.
The concerned Station House Officer (SHO) stated at the Bar that he had no prior knowledge of the termination and learned of both the procedure and the Court’s order only on November 20, when the fetal sample was handed over to him in the afternoon. The Court dispensed with his personal presence for the time being.
Recording its observations on the conduct of the health authorities, Justice Kazmi held, “Since this court had yet to pass some order which was within the knowledge of respondents, as such the respondents herein had no authority to terminate the pregnancy of minor victim without any authorization/direction from this court as this court was seized of the matter which was well within their knowledge.”
“However, despite having the knowledge that there would be risk to the life of the minor victim, the procedure was initiated by the team of doctors without even informing this court. Respondents have acted in clear violation of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971 as well as the relevant Rules on the subject,” the Court observed, adding that although an order regarding termination had been passed on November 20, the respondents “have taken the law in their hands thereby terminating the pregnancy beforehand.”
Directing the CMO, the MS, Respondent No. 5, the medical team, and the victim’s father to file personal affidavits before the next date of hearing, the Court instructed each of them to explain the role played in the procedure and their knowledge of the matter being sub-judice. They have also been ordered to specify whether they were “aware of the consequences in case the procedure undertaken without authorization of this court would have failed.” The government counsel has been directed to submit the complete record on November 25. (KDC)

